Revisiting the Optimal PMU Placement Problem in Multi-Machine Power Networks

TL;DR

This paper revisits the optimal PMU placement problem in multi-machine power networks by incorporating a nonlinear differential algebraic model, uncertainty, and advanced estimation techniques to improve observability and robustness.

Contribution

It introduces a comprehensive nonlinear NDAE model, discretization methods, and a moving horizon estimation approach for more accurate and robust PMU placement in power systems.

Findings

Validated approach on standard networks

Demonstrated robustness under various conditions

Improved observability with nonlinear modeling

Abstract

To provide real-time visibility of physics-based states, phasor measurement units (PMUs) are deployed throughout power networks. PMU data enable real-time grid monitoring and control -- and are essential in transitioning to smarter grids. Various considerations are taken into account when determining the geographic, optimal PMU placements (OPP). This paper focuses on the control-theoretic, observability aspect of OPP. A myriad of studies have investigated observability-based formulations to determine the OPP within a transmission network. However, they have mostly adopted a simplified representation of system dynamics, ignored basic algebraic equations that model power flows, disregarded including renewables such as solar and wind, and did not model their uncertainty. Consequently, this paper revisits the observability-based OPP problem by addressing the literature's limitations. A nonlinear differential algebraic representation (NDAE) of the power system is considered. The system is discretized using various discretization approaches while explicitly accounting for uncertainty. A moving horizon estimation approach is explored to reconstruct the joint differential and algebraic initial states of the system, as a gateway to the OPP problem which is then formulated as a computationally tractable integer program (IP). Comprehensive numerical simulations on standard power networks are conducted to validate the different aspects of this approach and test its robustness to various dynamical conditions.