Hyperbolic Active Learning for Semantic Segmentation under Domain Shift
Luca Franco, Paolo Mandica, Konstantinos Kallidromitis, Devin, Guillory, Yu-Teng Li, Trevor Darrell, Fabio Galasso

TL;DR
This paper presents HALO, a hyperbolic neural network-based active learning method for semantic segmentation under domain shift, utilizing epistemic uncertainty to select informative data points and outperforming supervised domain adaptation with minimal labels.
Contribution
Introducing a hyperbolic active learning approach that uses epistemic uncertainty for pixel-level data selection in semantic segmentation under domain shift.
Findings
HALO achieves state-of-the-art results in synthetic-to-real benchmarks.
HALO surpasses supervised domain adaptation performance with only 1% labeled data.
Effective use of hyperbolic radius and entropy to estimate epistemic uncertainty.
Abstract
We introduce a hyperbolic neural network approach to pixel-level active learning for semantic segmentation. Analysis of the data statistics leads to a novel interpretation of the hyperbolic radius as an indicator of data scarcity. In HALO (Hyperbolic Active Learning Optimization), for the first time, we propose the use of epistemic uncertainty as a data acquisition strategy, following the intuition of selecting data points that are the least known. The hyperbolic radius, complemented by the widely-adopted prediction entropy, effectively approximates epistemic uncertainty. We perform extensive experimental analysis based on two established synthetic-to-real benchmarks, i.e. GTAV Cityscapes and SYNTHIA Cityscapes. Additionally, we test HALO on Cityscape ACDC for domain adaptation under adverse weather conditions, and we benchmark both…
Peer Reviews
Decision·ICML 2024 Poster
1. It is interesting to see how Hypernolic neural network can benefit the active domain adaptation in semantic segmentation field. The proposed method achieves SOTA performance compared with the leveraged baselines. 2. Comprehensive ablations are done with great insights towards the proposed method. 3. The motivation is well described. The proposed method is described clearly and easy to understand. 4. The authors provided an interesting discussion towards Hyperbolic radius and the unexpla
1. The paper writing will limit this paper and still needs to be improved. For example, in Figure 3 and Figure 4, all the indexes ((a), (b), (c)...) are not marked on the Figures correspondingly. In text, the Figure is indicated by both Figure and Fig., which should be unified as the same. The authors are suggested to check the paper writing. 2. At the beginning of the Section 4.1, the authors claim that "Fig. 2a illustrates the correlation between the perclass average hyperbolic radius and the
- Hyperbolic NN for AL seems something new - The method is interesting as the paper proposes to let the HALO learn a manifold where the distance of a class from the center is directly proportional to the unexplained class complexity.
- The paper is not that easy to follow as there are missing details like how to get the embeddings of the pixels? Directly in the pixel space or get the feature first? How to plot the Figure 2? How to get the accuracy in Figure 2? - setting a new state-of-the-art across " all ADA benchmarks for SS" is overclaimed. - This is not correct: "Hyperbolic neural networks first extract a feature vector v in Euclidean space". Not necessary in Euclidean space (Fully HNN). - The conclusion seems problema
1. The observation that the hyperbolic radius is correlated with class difficulty and scarcity is interesting.
1. The correlation between hyperbolic radius and class complexity is only supported with some experimental evidence on GTAV->Cityscapes dataset. Actually, as the two aspects of class complexity considered in the paper, i.e., class difficulty and scarcity, are correlated by itself, the hyperbolic radius may be mostly affected by label scarcity. The coefficient factor (-0.605 vs. -0.899) also indicates that the hyperbolic radius is more correlated with label scarcity. More convincing support (i.e.
Code & Models
Videos
No videos yet. Explain this paper in a talk, walkthrough, or lecture? Add one.
Taxonomy
TopicsDomain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning · COVID-19 diagnosis using AI · Machine Learning and Algorithms
