$\beta^-$ decay $Q$-value measurement of $^{136}$Cs and its implications to neutrino studies

TL;DR

This paper precisely measures the $eta^-$ decay Q-value of $^{136}$Cs, revealing new insights into its decay states and implications for neutrino mass experiments, especially identifying the 3$^-$ state as a promising candidate.

Contribution

The study provides a significantly more precise Q-value measurement for $^{136}$Cs and clarifies the decay energetics, impacting neutrino mass research and decay state analysis.

Findings

Q-value determined as 2536.83(45) keV, much more precise than previous data.

Decay to the 4$^+$ state is energetically forbidden for neutrino mass studies.

Decay to the 3$^-$ state has a positive Q-value, making it suitable for neutrino mass determination.

Abstract

The $\beta^-$ decay $Q$-value of $^{136}$Cs ($J^\pi = 5^+$, $t_{1/2} \approx 13$~days) was measured with the JYFLTRAP Penning trap setup at the Ion Guide Isotope Separator On-Line (IGISOL) facility of the University of Jyv\"askyl\"a, Finland. The mono-isotopic samples required in the measurements were prepared with a new scheme utilised for the cleaning, based on the coupling of dipolar excitation with Ramsey's method of time-separated oscillatory fields and the phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance (PI-ICR) technique. The $Q$ value is determined to be 2536.83(45) keV, which is $\sim$4 times more precise and 11.4(20) keV ($\sim$ 6$\sigma$) smaller than the adopted value in the most recent Atomic Mass Evaluation AME2020. The daughter, $^{136}$Ba, has a 4$^+$ state at 2544.481(24) keV and a $3^-$ state at 2532.653(23) keV, both of which can potentially be ultralow $Q$-value end-states for the $^{136}$Cs decay. With our new ground-to-ground state $Q$ value, the decay energies to these two states become -7.65(45) keV and 4.18(45) keV, respectively. The former is confirmed to be negative at the level of $\sim$ 17$\sigma$, which verifies that this transition is not a suitable candidate for neutrino mass determination. On the other hand, the slightly negative $Q$ value makes this transition an interesting candidate for the study of virtual $\beta$-$\gamma$ transitions. The decay to the 3$^{-}$ state is validated to have a positive low $Q$ value which makes it a viable candidate for neutrino mass determination. For this transition, we obtained a shell-model-based half-life estimate of $2.1_{-0.8}^{+1.6}\times10^{12}$ yr.