Two is Better Than One: Digital Siblings to Improve Autonomous Driving Testing

TL;DR

This paper proposes a multi-simulator ensemble approach using digital siblings to improve the reliability of simulation-based testing for autonomous vehicles, demonstrating enhanced failure prediction accuracy over individual simulators.

Contribution

It introduces the concept of digital siblings, a multi-simulator ensemble method, to better predict failures in autonomous driving testing compared to single-simulator approaches.

Findings

Ensemble failure predictor outperforms individual simulators in failure prediction.

Multi-simulator approach reduces false negatives in testing.

Method improves reliability of simulation-based autonomous vehicle testing.

Abstract

Simulation-based testing represents an important step to ensure the reliability of autonomous driving software. In practice, when companies rely on third-party general-purpose simulators, either for in-house or outsourced testing, the generalizability of testing results to real autonomous vehicles is at stake. In this paper, we enhance simulation-based testing by introducing the notion of digital siblings, a multi-simulator approach that tests a given autonomous vehicle on multiple general-purpose simulators built with different technologies, that operate collectively as an ensemble in the testing process. We exemplify our approach on a case study focused on testing the lane-keeping component of an autonomous vehicle. We use two open-source simulators as digital siblings, and we empirically compare such a multi-simulator approach against a digital twin of a physical scaled autonomous vehicle on a large set of test cases. Our approach requires generating and running test cases for each individual simulator, in the form of sequences of road points. Then, test cases are migrated between simulators, using feature maps to characterize the exercised driving conditions. Finally, the joint predicted failure probability is computed, and a failure is reported only in cases of agreement among the siblings. Our empirical evaluation shows that the ensemble failure predictor by the digital siblings is superior to each individual simulator at predicting the failures of the digital twin. We discuss the findings of our case study and detail how our approach can help researchers interested in automated testing of autonomous driving software.