Comparison of behavioral systems theory and conventional linear models for predicting building zone temperature in long-term in situ measurements

TL;DR

This study compares behavioral systems theory and conventional linear models for predicting building zone temperature using long-term in situ data, highlighting their relative accuracy, computational efficiency, and data requirements.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive comparison of adaptive behavioral systems models and ARX models in real building environments without artificial excitation.

Findings

All methods achieve sufficient prediction accuracy.

ARX models perform slightly better and are computationally simpler.

Using recent data improves model performance.

Abstract

The potential of Model Predictive Control in buildings has been shown many times, being successfully used to achieve various goals, such as minimizing energy consumption or maximizing thermal comfort. However, mass deployment has thus far failed, in part because of the high engineering cost of obtaining and maintaining a sufficiently accurate model. This can be addressed by using adaptive data-driven approaches. The idea of using behavioral systems theory for this purpose has recently found traction in the academic community. In this study, we compare variations thereof with different amounts of data used, different regularization weights, and different methods of data selection. Autoregressive models with exogenous inputs (ARX) are used as a well-established reference. All methods are evaluated by performing iterative system identification on two long-term data sets from real occupied buildings, neither of which include artificial excitation for the purpose of system identification. We find that: (1) Sufficient prediction accuracy is achieved with all methods. (2) The ARX models perform slightly better, while having the additional advantages of fewer tuning parameters and faster computation. (3) Adaptive and non-adaptive schemes perform similarly. (4) The regularization weights of the behavioral systems theory methods show the expected trade-off characteristic with an optimal middle value. (5) Using the most recent data yields better performance than selecting data with similar weather as the day to be predicted. (6) More data improves the model performance.