Evidence to disfavour dual core system leading to double-peaked narrow emission lines

TL;DR

This paper proposes a method to test dual core systems causing double-peaked narrow emission lines, and applies it to SDSS J2219-0938, providing evidence against the dual core interpretation for this galaxy.

Contribution

The study introduces a flux ratio comparison method to distinguish dual core systems from other causes of double-peaked emission lines in galaxies.

Findings

Flux ratios differ from expected in dual core systems.

Double-peaked lines confirmed in main galaxy, single in companion.

Results disfavour dual core system in SDSS J2219-0938.

Abstract

In this manuscript, an interesting method is proposed to test dual core system for double-peaked narrow emission lines, through precious dual core system with double-peaked narrow Balmer lines in one system in main galaxy but with single-peaked narrow Balmer lines in the other system in companion galaxy. Under a dual core system, considering narrow Balmer (H$\alpha$ and H$\beta$) emissions ($f_{e,~\alpha}$ and $f_{e,~\beta}$) from companion galaxy but covered by SDSS fiber for the main galaxy and narrow Balmer emissions ($f_{c,~\alpha}$ and $f_{c,~\beta}$) from the companion galaxy covered by SDSS fiber for the companion galaxy, the same flux ratios $f_{e,~\alpha}/f_{c,~\alpha}=f_{e,~\beta}/f_{c,~\beta}$ can be expected, due to totally similar physical conditions of each narrow Balmer emission region. Then, the precious dual core system in SDSS J2219-0938 is discussed. After subtracting pPXF code determined stellar lights, double-peaked narrow Balmer emission lines are confirmed in the main galaxy with confidence level higher than $5\sigma$, but single-peaked narrow Balmer emission lines in the companion galaxy. Through measured fluxes of emission components, $f_{e,~\alpha}/f_{c,~\alpha}$ is around 0.82, different from $f_{e,~\beta}/f_{c,~\beta}\sim0.52$, to disfavour a dual core system for the double-peaked narrow Balmer emission lines in SDSS J2219-0938.