Heat-flux Fluctuations reveals regime transitions in Rayleigh-B\'enard convection

TL;DR

This paper identifies a clear transition in Rayleigh-Bénard convection regimes by analyzing heat flux fluctuations, revealing a sharp change at a specific Rayleigh number ratio, supported by numerical and analytical evidence.

Contribution

The study introduces a novel method of detecting regime transitions in thermal convection through heat flux fluctuation analysis, extending understanding at high Rayleigh numbers.

Findings

Transition occurs at Ra/Pr ≈ 10^9, marked by a jump in fluctuation ratio.

Above the transition, fluctuation ratio is constant across flow regions.

Below the transition, boundary fluctuations decrease with Rayleigh number, bulk remains constant.

Abstract

The study of the transitions among different regimes in thermal convection has been an issue of paramount importance in fluid mechanics. While the bifurcations at low Rayleigh number, when the flow is laminar or moderately chaotic, have been fully understood for a long time, transitions at higher Rayleigh number are much more difficult to be clearly identified. Here, through a numerical study of the two-dimensional Rayleigh-B\'enard convection covering four decades in Rayleigh number for two different Prandtl numbers, we find a clear-cut transition by considering the fluctuations of the heat flux through a horizontal plane, rather than its mean value. More specifically, we have found that this sharp transition is displayed by a jump of the ratio of the root-mean-square fluctuations of the heat flux to its mean value and occurs at $Ra/Pr \approx 10^9$. Above the transition, this ratio is found to be constant in all regions of the flow, while taking different values in the bulk and at the boundaries. Below the transition instead, different behaviors are observed at the boundaries and in the bulk: at the boundaries, this ratio decreases with respect to the Rayleigh number whereas it is found to be constant in the bulk for all values of the Rayleigh number. Through this numerical evidence and an analytical reasoning we confirm what was already observed in experiments, that is the decrease of the ratio of root-mean-square fluctuations of the heat flux to its mean value, observed at the boundaries below the transition, can understood in terms of the law of large numbers.