Cold Dust and Low [OIII]/[CII] Ratios: an Evolved Star-forming Population at Redshift 7

TL;DR

This study presents ALMA observations of three massive galaxies at redshift 7, revealing cold dust, high dust masses, and low [OIII]/[CII] ratios, indicating a mature, steady star-forming galaxy population in the early universe.

Contribution

First detection of cold dust and low ionization line ratios in massive $z oughly7$ galaxies, suggesting evolved, steady star formation in early universe galaxies.

Findings

Detected cold dust with temperatures 30-35 K in two galaxies.

Found low [OIII]/[CII] ratios around unity, lower than typical high-redshift galaxies.

Evidence for a mature, dust-rich galaxy population with steady star formation at $z oughly7$.

Abstract

We present new ALMA Band 8 (rest-frame $90\,\mu$m) observations of three massive ($M_\star \approx 10^{10}\,M_\odot$) galaxies at $z\approx7$ previously detected in [CII]$158\,\mu$m and underlying dust continuum emission in the Reionization Era Bright Emission Line Survey (REBELS). We detect the dust continuum emission of two of our targets in Band 8 (REBELS-25 and REBELS-38), while REBELS-12 remains undetected. Through modified blackbody fitting we determine cold dust temperatures ($T_\mathrm{dust} \approx 30 - 35\,$K) in both of the dual-band detected targets, given a fiducial model of optically thin emission with $\beta = 2.0$. Their dust temperatures are lower than most $z\sim7$ galaxies in the literature, and consequently their dust masses are higher ($M_\mathrm{dust} \approx 10^{8}\,M_\odot$). Nevertheless, these large dust masses are still consistent with predictions from models of dust production in the early Universe. In addition, we target and detect [OIII]$88\,\mu$m emission in both REBELS-12 and REBELS-25, and find $L_\mathrm{[OIII]} / L_\mathrm{[CII]}$ ratios of approximately unity, low compared to the $L_\mathrm{[OIII]} / L_\mathrm{[CII]} \gtrsim 2 - 10$ observed in the known $z\gtrsim6$ population thus far. We argue the lower line ratios are due to a comparatively weaker ionizing radiation field resulting from the less starbursty nature of our targets. This low burstiness supports the cold dust temperatures and below average $\mathrm{[OIII]}\lambda\lambda4959,5007 + \mathrm{H}\beta$ equivalent widths of REBELS-25 and REBELS-38, compared to the known high-redshift population. Overall, this provides evidence for the existence of a massive, dust-rich galaxy population at $z\approx7$ which has previously experienced vigorous star formation, but is currently forming stars in a steady, as opposed to bursty, manner.