Examples for Scalar Sphere Stability

TL;DR

This paper provides new examples related to scalar curvature stability conjectures, highlighting the importance of minimal surface area conditions and introducing improved construction techniques for scalar curvature manipulation.

Contribution

It introduces the first examples addressing scalar sphere stability conjectures, including conditions on minimal surfaces and advanced construction methods for scalar curvature control.

Findings

Necessity of minimal surface area conditions to prevent bubbling.

Sequences that converge in volume preserving intrinsic flat sense but not in Gromov-Hausdorff sense.

Improved Gromov-Lawson tunnel construction for scalar curvature manipulation.

Abstract

The rigidity theorems of Llarull and Marques-Neves, which show two different ways scalar curvature can characterize the sphere, have associated stability conjectures. Here we produce the first examples related to these stability conjectures. The first set of examples demonstrates the necessity of including a condition on the minimum area of all minimal surfaces to prevent bubbling along the sequence. The second set of examples constructs sequences that do not converge in the Gromov-Hausdorff sense but do converge in the volume preserving intrinsic flat sense. In order to construct such sequences, we improve the Gromov-Lawson tunnel construction so that one can attach wells and tunnels to a manifold with scalar curvature bounded below and only decrease the scalar curvature by an arbitrarily small amount. Moreover, we are able to generalize both the sewing construction of Basilio, Dodziuk, and Sormani, and the construction due to Basilio, Kazaras, and Sormani of an intrinsic flat limit with no geodesics.