New trends in South-South migration: The economic impact of COVID-19 and immigration enforcement

TL;DR

This study examines how COVID-19 and border enforcement affected Guatemalan emigration, revealing increased family travel and economic factors as key influences on migration trends during 2017-2020.

Contribution

It provides new insights into migration patterns during the pandemic, highlighting economic shocks and enforcement policies as drivers of increased family migration.

Findings

Migration from Guatemala decreased by 10% overall.

Migration with children increased by nearly 30%.

Economic shocks influenced migration more than violence.

Abstract

This paper evaluates the impact of the pandemic and enforcement at the US and Mexican borders on the emigration of Guatemalans during 2017-2020. During this period, the number of crossings from Guatemala fell by 10%, according to the Survey of Migration to the Southern Border of Mexico. Yet, there was a rise of nearly 30% in the number of emigration crossings of male adults travelling with their children. This new trend was partly driven by the recent reduction in the number of children deported from the US. For a one-point reduction in the number of children deported from the US to Guatemalan municipalities, there was an increase of nearly 14 in the number of crossings made by adult males leaving from Guatemala for Mexico; and nearly 0.5 additional crossings made by male adults travelling with their children. However, the surge of emigrants travelling with their children was also driven by the acute economic shock that Guatemala experienced during the pandemic. During this period, air pollution in the analysed Guatemalan municipalities fell by 4%, night light per capita fell by 15%, and homicide rates fell by 40%. Unlike in previous years, emigrants are fleeing poverty rather than violence. Our findings suggest that a reduction in violence alone will not be sufficient to reduce emigration flows from Central America, but that economic recovery is needed.