Interpretation of Radio Afterglows in the framework of the Standard Fireball and Energy Injection models

TL;DR

This study compiles and analyzes radio afterglow data from 82 GRBs to test the standard fireball model using closure relations, revealing that less than half of the cases are compatible with the model, especially favoring the ISM environment.

Contribution

It provides the most comprehensive radio afterglow dataset to date and systematically tests the fireball model against multiple density profiles and energy injection scenarios.

Findings

46% of GRBs fulfill at least one closure relation

ISM environment with no energy injection is most consistent

Data largely incompatible with the standard fireball model

Abstract

Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) are panchromatic, highly energetic transients whose energy emission mechanism is still debated. One of the possible explanations is the standard fireball model, which can be tested with the closure relations (CRs), or relations between the temporal and spectral indices of a GRB. To test these, we compile an extensive sample of radio afterglow light curves (LCs) that span from 1997 to 2020, the most comprehensive analysis of GRBs with radio observations to date. We fit 202 LCs from 82 distinct GRBs with a broken power law, obtaining a sample of 26 that display a clear break and a subsample of 14 GRBs that present a radio plateau. We test these samples against CRs corresponding to a constant-density interstellar medium (ISM) or a stellar wind medium in both fast- and slow-cooling regimes, as well as three additional density profiles, $k = 1, 1.5, 2.5,$ following $n \propto r^{-k}$ , and consider sets of CRs both with and without energy injection. We find that 12 of the 26 GRBs (46%), of which 7/12 present a radio plateau, fulfill at least one CR in the sets tested, suggesting our data is largely incompatible with the standard fireball model. Of the fulfilled CRs, the most preferred environment is the ISM, SC, $\nu_m < \nu < \nu_c$ without energy injection. Our results are consistent with previous studies that test the standard fireball model via the CRs in radio.