An Accessible Method for Simulating Charged-Particle Optics, with Examples for Transmission Electron Microscopy

TL;DR

This paper presents an accessible simulation method using COMSOL Multiphysics to model charged-particle optics in TEM, enabling rapid, cost-effective exploration of new lens designs without physical modifications.

Contribution

It introduces a user-friendly 'digital twin' simulation approach for TEM optics, facilitating innovation without risking instrument integrity or incurring high costs.

Findings

Simulation method accurately models TEM lens behavior

Allows rapid testing of new optical geometries

Encourages grassroots innovation in TEM design

Abstract

The transmission electron microscope (TEM) has become an essential tool for innovation in nanoscience, material science, and biology. Despite these instruments being widely used across both industry and academia, academics may hesitate to propose substantial modifications to the optical setup due to the instrument's significant purchase price, fear of voiding the service contract, or downtime being unacceptable in shared user facilities. For instruments found in industry, similarly the risk-reward balance makes substantive modifications untenable. This limits the development of radically new optical geometries, and with the performance of the TEM largely being dictated by the specification of the objective lens pole-piece, exploring novel designs may be valuable. Alternatively, potential lens designs can be analyzed rapidly and inexpensively using finite element analysis multiphysics simulation packages. Several are available, but here COMSOL Multiphysics was used, which is readily available in many universities. Changes to the geometry or materials of the lens can be investigated without any need to disassemble, reassemble, and realign the TEM column. Here we demonstrate an intuitive and accessible method to simulate charged particle optics using this 'digital twin' approach, with the hope that this encourages new creative and sustainable grassroots innovation in TEM lens design and microscope modification.