Mixed Signals: Analyzing Software Attribution Challenges in the Android Ecosystem

TL;DR

This paper empirically investigates the challenges of author attribution in the Android ecosystem, revealing the unreliability of common signals like metadata and signing certificates due to their volatility and misuse.

Contribution

It provides the first comprehensive empirical analysis of attribution signals in Android markets and introduces the attribution graph to evaluate their validity.

Findings

Market metadata is often missing or volatile over time.

Signing certificates are shared among different authors, reducing their reliability.

The attribution graph reveals the confusion caused by unreliable signals.

Abstract

The ability to identify the author responsible for a given software object is critical for many research studies and for enhancing software transparency and accountability. However, as opposed to other application markets like iOS, attribution in the Android ecosystem is known to be hard. Prior research has leveraged market metadata and signing certificates to identify software authors without questioning the validity and accuracy of these attribution signals. However, Android app authors can, either intentionally or by mistake, hide their true identity due to: (1) the lack of policy enforcement by markets to ensure the accuracy and correctness of the information disclosed by developers in their market profiles during the app release process, and (2) the use of self-signed certificates for signing apps instead of certificates issued by trusted CAs. In this paper, we perform the first empirical analysis of the availability, volatility and overall aptness of publicly available metadata for author attribution in Android app markets. To that end, we analyze a dataset of over 2.5 million market entries and apps extracted from five Android markets for over two years. Our results show that widely used attribution signals are often missing from market profiles and that they change over time. We also invalidate the general belief about the validity of signing certificates for author attribution. For instance, we find that apps from different authors share signing certificates due to the proliferation of app building frameworks and software factories. Finally, we introduce the concept of attribution graph and we apply it to evaluate the validity of existing attribution signals on the Google Play Store. Our results confirm that the lack of control over publicly available signals can confuse the attribution process.