Analytical Estimation of Beamforming Speed-of-Sound Using Transmission Geometry

TL;DR

This paper introduces an analytical method to accurately estimate and correct the beamforming speed-of-sound in ultrasound imaging, significantly improving image resolution and reducing artifacts.

Contribution

We develop a closed-form analytical model for estimating and iteratively correcting beamforming speed-of-sound errors in ultrasound imaging.

Findings

Lateral B-mode resolution improved by approximately 25%.

BF SoS errors reduced to under 1 m/s in experiments.

Residual time-delay errors decreased to 0.07 μs, with up to 21-fold improvement.

Abstract

Most ultrasound imaging techniques necessitate the fundamental step of converting temporal signals received from transducer elements into a spatial echogenecity map. This beamforming (BF) step requires the knowledge of speed-of-sound (SoS) value in the imaged medium. An incorrect assumption of BF SoS leads to aberration artifacts, not only deteriorating the quality and resolution of conventional brightness mode (B-mode) images, hence limiting their clinical usability, but also impairing other ultrasound modalities such as elastography and spatial SoS reconstructions, which rely on faithfully beamformed images as their input. In this work, we propose an analytical method for estimating BF SoS. We show that pixel-wise relative shifts between frames beamformed with an assumed SoS is a function of geometric disparities of the transmission paths and the error in such SoS assumption. Using this relation, we devise an analytical model, the closed form solution of which yields the difference between the assumed and the true SoS in the medium. Based on this, we correct the BF SoS, which can also be applied iteratively. Both in simulations and experiments, lateral B-mode resolution is shown to be improved by $\approx$25% compared to that with an initial SoS assumption error of 3.3% (50 m/s), while localization artifacts from beamforming are also corrected. After 5 iterations, our method achieves BF SoS errors of under 0.6 m/s in simulations and under 1 m/s in experimental phantom data. Residual time-delay errors in beamforming 32 numerical phantoms are shown to reduce down to 0.07 $\mu$s, with average improvements of up to 21 folds compared to initial inaccurate assumptions. We additionally show the utility of the proposed method in imaging local SoS maps, where using our correction method reduces reconstruction root-mean-square errors substantially, down to their lower-bound with actual BF SoS.