A Unified Framework for Quantifying Privacy Risk in Synthetic Data

TL;DR

This paper introduces Anonymeter, a comprehensive framework for quantifying privacy risks in synthetic data, including attack-based evaluations aligned with GDPR, and demonstrates its effectiveness through extensive experiments.

Contribution

We present the first coherent, legally aligned evaluation framework for privacy risks in synthetic data, including novel attack models for singling out and linkability.

Findings

Privacy risks scale linearly with leakage levels.

Synthetic data shows low vulnerability to linkability attacks.

Anonymeter outperforms existing methods in detection and speed.

Abstract

Synthetic data is often presented as a method for sharing sensitive information in a privacy-preserving manner by reproducing the global statistical properties of the original data without disclosing sensitive information about any individual. In practice, as with other anonymization methods, privacy risks cannot be entirely eliminated. The residual privacy risks need instead to be ex-post assessed. We present Anonymeter, a statistical framework to jointly quantify different types of privacy risks in synthetic tabular datasets. We equip this framework with attack-based evaluations for the singling out, linkability, and inference risks, the three key indicators of factual anonymization according to the European General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to introduce a coherent and legally aligned evaluation of these three privacy risks for synthetic data, and to design privacy attacks which model directly the singling out and linkability risks. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our methods by conducting an extensive set of experiments that measure the privacy risks of data with deliberately inserted privacy leakages, and of synthetic data generated with and without differential privacy. Our results highlight that the three privacy risks reported by our framework scale linearly with the amount of privacy leakage in the data. Furthermore, we observe that synthetic data exhibits the lowest vulnerability against linkability, indicating one-to-one relationships between real and synthetic data records are not preserved. Finally, we demonstrate quantitatively that Anonymeter outperforms existing synthetic data privacy evaluation frameworks both in terms of detecting privacy leaks, as well as computation speed. To contribute to a privacy-conscious usage of synthetic data, we open source Anonymeter at https://github.com/statice/anonymeter.