No Privacy in the Electronics Repair Industry

TL;DR

This study reveals widespread privacy violations in the electronics repair industry, highlighting the lack of safeguards for personal data and proposing stakeholder actions to improve privacy protections.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive four-part investigation into privacy breaches in electronics repair, including field studies, data collection, surveys, and interviews, revealing systemic issues.

Findings

Most providers lack privacy policies.

Technicians snoop and copy personal data.

Customers experience significant privacy violations.

Abstract

Electronics repair and service providers offer a range of services to computing device owners across North America -- from software installation to hardware repair. Device owners obtain these services and leave their device along with their access credentials at the mercy of technicians, which leads to privacy concerns for owners' personal data. We conduct a comprehensive four-part study to measure the state of privacy in the electronics repair industry. First, through a field study with 18 service providers, we uncover that most service providers do not have any privacy policy or controls to safeguard device owners' personal data from snooping by technicians. Second, we drop rigged devices for repair at 16 service providers and collect data on widespread privacy violations by technicians, including snooping on personal data, copying data off the device, and removing tracks of snooping activities. Third, we conduct an online survey (n=112) to collect data on customers' experiences when getting devices repaired. Fourth, we invite a subset of survey respondents (n=30) for semi-structured interviews to establish a deeper understanding of their experiences and identify potential solutions to curtail privacy violations by technicians. We apply our findings to discuss possible controls and actions different stakeholders and regulatory agencies should take to improve the state of privacy in the repair industry.