Benchmarking Language Models for Code Syntax Understanding

TL;DR

This paper benchmarks pre-trained language models on their ability to understand code syntax, revealing significant gaps and limitations in current models' understanding of programming language structures.

Contribution

It introduces CodeSyntax, a large-scale dataset for evaluating code syntax understanding, and provides a comprehensive benchmark highlighting the deficiencies of existing models.

Findings

Pre-trained models perform poorly on code syntax tasks.

Simple baselines outperform complex pre-trained models in syntax understanding.

Existing pre-training methods lack effective modeling of code structures.

Abstract

Pre-trained language models have demonstrated impressive performance in both natural language processing and program understanding, which represent the input as a token sequence without explicitly modeling its structure. Some prior works show that pre-trained language models can capture the syntactic rules of natural languages without finetuning on syntax understanding tasks. However, there is limited understanding of how well pre-trained models understand the code structure so far. In this work, we perform the first thorough benchmarking of the state-of-the-art pre-trained models for identifying the syntactic structures of programs. Specifically, we introduce CodeSyntax, a large-scale dataset of programs annotated with the syntactic relationships in their corresponding abstract syntax trees. Our key observation is that existing language models pretrained on code still lack the understanding of code syntax. In fact, these pre-trained programming language models fail to match the performance of simple baselines based on positional offsets and keywords. We also present a natural language benchmark to highlight the differences between natural languages and programming languages in terms of syntactic structure understanding. Our findings point out key limitations of existing pre-training methods for programming languages, and suggest the importance of modeling code syntactic structures.