The Quenched Satellite Population Around Milky Way Analogs

TL;DR

This study compares the fractions of quenched and star-forming satellite galaxies around Milky Way-like galaxies using two surveys, revealing broad agreement but some discrepancies with the Local Group and simulations.

Contribution

It provides a detailed comparison of satellite galaxy quenching fractions across different surveys and definitions, highlighting the importance of consistent criteria.

Findings

Quenched fraction decreases from ~50% to ~27% after magnitude cut.

Results are consistent across different star-formation definitions.

Some tension exists between observed fractions and simulations or the Local Group.

Abstract

We study the relative fractions of quenched and star-forming satellite galaxies in the Satellites Around Galactic Analogs (SAGA) survey and Exploration of Local VolumE Satellites (ELVES) program, two nearby and complementary samples of Milky Way-like galaxies that take different approaches to identify faint satellite galaxy populations. We cross-check and validate sample cuts and selection criteria, as well as explore the effects of different star-formation definitions when determining the quenched satellite fraction of Milky Way analogs. We find the mean ELVES quenched fraction ($\langle QF\rangle$), derived using a specific star formation rate (sSFR) threshold, decreases from $\sim$50% to $\sim$27% after applying a cut in absolute magnitude to match that of the SAGA survey ($\langle QF\rangle_{SAGA}\sim$9%). We show these results are consistent for alternative star-formation definitions. Furthermore, these quenched fractions remain virtually unchanged after applying an additional cut in surface brightness. Using a consistently-derived sSFR and absolute magnitude limit for both samples, we show that the quenched fraction and the cumulative number of satellites in the ELVES and SAGA samples broadly agree. We briefly explore radial trends in the ELVES and SAGA samples, finding general agreement in the number of star-forming satellites per host as a function of radius. Despite the broad agreement between the ELVES and SAGA samples, some tension remains with these quenched fractions in comparison to the Local Group and simulations of Milky Way analogs.