Circularity of Thermodynamical Material Networks: Indicators, Examples, and Algorithms

TL;DR

This paper introduces indicators and algorithms for analyzing the circularity of thermodynamical material networks (TMNs), providing a dynamic, energy-based approach to designing sustainable material flows with practical examples and open-source code.

Contribution

It develops novel circularity indicators for TMNs using a graph-based formalism and demonstrates their application through numerical examples for fluid and solid materials.

Findings

Indicators effectively measure TMN circularity.

Numerical examples illustrate the indicators' calculation.

Open-source code enables practical implementation.

Abstract

The transition towards a circular economy has gained importance over the last years since the traditional linear take-make-dispose paradigm is not sustainable in the long term. Recently, thermodynamical material networks (TMNs) [1] have been proposed as an approach to design material flows based on the idea that any supply chain can be seen as a set of thermodynamic compartments that can be added, removed, modified or connected differently. Compared to the well-established material flow analysis (MFA), TMNs leverage dynamical energy balances and ordinary differential equations along with the usual mass balances, thus tackling circular economy as a material network design problem analogous to traditional engineering design approaches (e.g., design of thermodynamic cycles, electrical and hydraulic networks) rather than as an analysis of stock-and-flow data. Hence, TMNs allow the depiction of highly dynamic material stocks and flows whose variations can occur in less than 1 minute; achieving such modelling accuracy with MFA would be more data intensive. In this paper, we first develop several circularity indicators of TMNs using a graph-based formalism. Then, we illustrate their calculation using two numerical examples for the case of fluid materials and one numerical example for the case of solid materials, for which the detailed hybrid dynamical equations and simulation outputs are provided. The paper source code is publicly available.