Evolutionary Dynamics of Sustainable Blockchains

TL;DR

This paper models the evolutionary dynamics of blockchain miners and users to explore conditions under which Proof-of-Work blockchains can reduce energy consumption and become more sustainable.

Contribution

It introduces the Crypto-Asset Game, an evolutionary game theory model analyzing strategies of miners and users to identify pathways to lower energy use.

Findings

Population can reach low-miner strategies under certain conditions

Protocol parameters influence overall energy consumption

Model suggests potential for sustainable Proof-of-Work blockchains

Abstract

The energy sustainability of blockchains, whose consensus protocol rests on the Proof-of-Work, nourishes a heated debate. The underlying issue lies in a highly energy-consuming process, defined as mining, required to validate crypto-asset transactions. Mining is the process of solving a cryptographic puzzle, incentivised by the possibility of gaining a reward. The higher the number of users performing mining, i.e. miners, the higher the overall electricity consumption of a blockchain. For that reason, mining constitutes a negative environmental externality. Here, we study whether miners' interests can meet the collective need to curb energy consumption. To this end, we introduce the Crypto-Asset Game, namely a model based on the framework of Evolutionary Game Theory devised for studying the dynamics of a population whose agents can play as crypto-asset users or as miners. The energy consumption of mining impacts the payoff of both strategies, representing a direct cost for miners and an environmental factor for crypto-asset users. The proposed model, studied via numerical simulations, shows that, in some conditions, the agent population can reach a strategy profile that optimises global energy consumption, i.e. composed of a low density of miners. To conclude, can a Proof-of-Work-based blockchain become energetically sustainable? Our results suggest that blockchain protocol parameters could have a relevant role in the global energy consumption of this technology.