Tilting Uranus via the migration of an ancient satellite

TL;DR

This paper explores a novel hypothesis that a migrating ancient satellite could have tilted Uranus to its current high obliquity through spin-orbit resonance, challenging the impact-only explanation.

Contribution

It demonstrates that a single migrating satellite of specific mass and drift rate can effectively tilt Uranus, providing an alternative to impact-based theories.

Findings

A satellite with at least 4e-4 Uranus mass can tilt the planet over 80°.

The tilt can be achieved within the Solar System's age if the satellite's drift rate is comparable to the Moon's.

The satellite's destabilization leads to a chaotic phase and eventual collision, fixing Uranus's obliquity.

Abstract

Context. The 98{\deg}-obliquity of Uranus is commonly attributed to giant impacts that occurred at the end of the planetary formation. This picture, however, is not devoid of weaknesses. Aims. On a billion-year timescale, the tidal migration of the satellites of Jupiter and Saturn has been shown to strongly affect their spin-axis dynamics. We aim to revisit the scenario of tilting Uranus in light of this mechanism. Methods. We analyse the precession spectrum of Uranus and identify the candidate secular spin-orbit resonances that could be responsible for the tilting. We determine the properties of the hypothetical ancient satellite required for a capture and explore the dynamics numerically. Results. If it migrates over 10 Uranus' radii, a single satellite with minimum mass 4e-4 Uranus' mass is able to tilt Uranus from a small obliquity and make it converge towards 90{\deg}. In order to achieve the tilting in less than the age of the Solar System, the mean drift rate of the satellite must be comparable to the Moon's current orbital expansion. Under these conditions, simulations show that Uranus is readily tilted over 80{\deg}. Beyond this point, the satellite is strongly destabilised and triggers a phase of chaotic motion for the planet's spin axis. The chaotic phase ends when the satellite collides into the planet, ultimately freezing the planet's obliquity in either a prograde, or plainly retrograde state (as Uranus today). Spin states resembling that of Uranus can be obtained with probabilities as large as 80%, but a bigger satellite is favoured, with mass 1.7e-3 Uranus' mass or more. Yet, a smaller ancient satellite is not categorically ruled out, and there is room for improving this basic scenario in future studies. Interactions among several pre-existing satellites is a promising possibility.