Benchmarking magnetized three-wave coupling for laser backscattering: Analytic solutions and kinetic simulations

TL;DR

This paper benchmarks magnetized three-wave coupling coefficients in laser-plasma interactions using particle-in-cell simulations, validating warm-fluid theory predictions across various parameters and identifying kinetic effects.

Contribution

It provides a rigorous comparison between warm-fluid theory and kinetic simulations for magnetized three-wave coupling in laser backscattering.

Findings

Excellent agreement between theory and simulations for a wide parameter range.

Warm-fluid theory is valid for many conditions but kinetic effects are observed.

A systematic protocol for benchmarking theory with simulations is established.

Abstract

Understanding magnetized laser-plasma interactions is important for controlling magneto-inertial fusion experiments and developing magnetically assisted radiation and particle sources. In the long-pulse regime, interactions are dominated by coherent three-wave interactions, whose nonlinear coupling coefficients become known only recently when waves propagate at oblique angles with the magnetic field. In this paper, backscattering coupling coefficients predicted by warm-fluid theory is benchmarked using particle-in-cell simulations in one spatial dimension, and excellent agreements are found for a wide range of plasma temperatures, magnetic field strengths, and laser propagation angles, when the interactions are mediated by electron-dominant hybrid waves. Systematic comparisons between theory and simulations are made possible by a rigorous protocol: On the theory side, the initial boundary value problem of linearized three-wave equations is solved, and the transient-time solutions allow effects of growth and damping to be distinguished. On the simulation side, parameters are carefully chosen and calibration runs are performed to ensure that stimulated runs are well controlled. Fitting simulation data to analytical solutions yields numerical growth rates, which match theory predictions within error bars. Although warm-fluid theory is found to be valid for a wide parameter range, genuine kinetic effects have also been observed.