Similarities between characteristics of convective turbulence in confined and extended domains

TL;DR

This study investigates turbulent convection in slender cylindrical cells, revealing how velocity and temperature fluctuations vary with Prandtl number and showing similarities with larger aspect ratio and 2D convection.

Contribution

It demonstrates that turbulent fluctuation characteristics in confined and extended domains share key features, especially regarding Prandtl number dependence.

Findings

Fluctuations weaken with increasing Prandtl number.

Temperature fluctuation PDFs remain mostly Gaussian in the bulk.

Turbulent Prandtl number scales as Pr^{-1/3}.

Abstract

To understand turbulent convection at very high Rayleigh numbers typical of natural phenomena, computational studies in slender cells are an option if the needed resources have to be optimized within available limits. However, the accompanying horizontal confinement affects some properties of the flow. Here, we explore the characteristics of turbulent fluctuations in the velocity and temperature fields in a cylindrical convection cell of aspect ratio 0.1 by varying the Prandtl number $Pr$ between 0.1 and 200 at a fixed Rayleigh number $Ra = 3 \times 10^{10}$, and find that the fluctuations weaken with increasing $Pr$, quantitatively as in aspect ratio 25. The probability density function (PDF) of temperature fluctuations in the bulk region of the slender cell remains mostly Gaussian, but increasing departures occur as $Pr$ increases beyond unity. We assess the intermittency of the velocity field by computing the PDFs of velocity derivatives and of the kinetic energy dissipation rate, and find increasing intermittency as $Pr$ decreases. In the bulk region of convection, a common result applicable to the slender cell, large aspect ratio cells, as well as in 2D convection, is that the turbulent Prandtl number decreases as $Pr^{-1/3}$.