Black hole spectroscopy: prospects for testing the nature of black holes with gravitational wave observations

TL;DR

This paper explores the potential of gravitational wave observations to perform black hole spectroscopy, aiming to test the no-hair theorem by detecting multiple quasinormal modes from black hole mergers.

Contribution

It analyzes the detectability of subdominant quasinormal modes, especially overtones, and estimates the horizons for current and future gravitational wave detectors to observe these modes.

Findings

Overtone mode (2,2,1) has high amplitude, comparable to higher harmonic modes.

Future detectors can potentially detect multiple quasinormal modes from black hole mergers.

Event rate for detecting subdominant modes with LIGO is promising.

Abstract

Gravitational waves provide direct information about the nature of spacetime and the existence of black holes. The remnant of a binary black hole merger emits gravitational waves in the form of quasinormal modes, whose spectrum is known as the "fingerprints" of a black hole, as it depends only on the properties of the remnant. The quasinormal modes can be used to test how closely an astrophysical black hole matches the Kerr geometry. Each mode is parameterized by three indices: the harmonic numbers $(\ell, m)$ and the overtone index $n$, that labels the fundamental mode ($n = 0$) and the overtones ($n = 1,2,3,\ldots$). Black hole spectroscopy is the proposal to use the detection of multiple quasinormal modes to test the no-hair theorem. In this work, we investigate the prospects for performing black hole spectroscopy. The $(2,2,0)$ is the dominant mode, and we analyze the contribution of the most relevant subdominant modes in numerical relativity simulations. We show that the overtone mode $(2,2,1)$ has an amplitude higher or comparable to the amplitude of the most relevant higher harmonic modes. For current and future gravitational wave detectors, we compute the black hole spectroscopy horizon, which is the maximum distance of an event up to which two or more quasinormal modes can be detected. For low mass ratio binaries, the secondary and tertiary modes are the $(2,2,1)$ and $(3,3,0)$, respectively, and, for the large mass ratio case, the $(3,3,0)$ and $(4,4,0)$ are the most relevant subdominant modes for detection. Our work indicates promising prospects for the detection of subdominant modes with future gravitational wave detectors. The event rate for LIGO is much smaller, but not prohibitively so.