Magnetic Misalignment of Interstellar Dust Filaments

TL;DR

This paper investigates the scale-independent misalignment between interstellar dust filaments and magnetic fields using Planck and HI4PI data, revealing a consistent misalignment angle and its implications for cosmic birefringence searches.

Contribution

It introduces new estimators for measuring dust-magnetic field misalignment and demonstrates their application to large sky regions, revealing correlations with polarization spectra.

Findings

Global misalignment angle of ~2° robust across masks

Misalignment correlates with the Planck TB spectrum

HI-based dust polarization template shows strong correlation with Planck B modes

Abstract

We present evidence for scale-independent misalignment of interstellar dust filaments and magnetic fields. We estimate the misalignment by comparing millimeter-wave dust-polarization measurements from Planck with filamentary structures identified in neutral-hydrogen (HI) measurements from HI4PI. We find that the misalignment angle displays a scale independence (harmonic coherence) for features larger than the HI4PI beam width ($16.2'$). We additionally find a spatial coherence on angular scales of $\mathcal{O}(1^\circ)$. We present several misalignment estimators formed from the auto- and cross-spectra of dust-polarization and HI-based maps, and we also introduce a map-space estimator. Applied to large regions of the high-Galactic-latitude sky, we find a global misalignment angle of $\sim 2^\circ$, which is robust to a variety of masking choices. By dividing the sky into small regions, we show that the misalignment angle correlates with the parity-violating $TB$ cross-spectrum measured in the Planck dust maps. The misalignment paradigm also predicts a dust $EB$ signal, which is of relevance in the search for cosmic birefringence but as yet undetected; the measurements of $EB$ are noisier than of $TB$, and our correlations of $EB$ with misalignment angle are found to be weaker and less robust to masking choices. We also introduce an HI-based dust-polarization template constructed from the Hessian matrix of the HI intensity, which is found to correlate more strongly than previous templates with Planck dust $B$ modes.