Unsupervised Question Clarity Prediction Through Retrieved Item Coherency

TL;DR

This paper introduces an unsupervised method for predicting when a conversational question needs clarification by analyzing the coherence of retrieved results, improving system responsiveness without requiring labeled data.

Contribution

It proposes a novel unsupervised approach based on graph connectivity of retrieved items to detect ambiguity, outperforming supervised methods in generalization.

Findings

Unsupervised method matches supervised performance.

Graph connectivity effectively indicates query ambiguity.

Approach generalizes well across datasets.

Abstract

Despite recent progress on conversational systems, they still do not perform smoothly and coherently when faced with ambiguous requests. When questions are unclear, conversational systems should have the ability to ask clarifying questions, rather than assuming a particular interpretation or simply responding that they do not understand. Previous studies have shown that users are more satisfied when asked a clarifying question, rather than receiving an unrelated response. While the research community has paid substantial attention to the problem of predicting query ambiguity in traditional search contexts, researchers have paid relatively little attention to predicting when this ambiguity is sufficient to warrant clarification in the context of conversational systems. In this paper, we propose an unsupervised method for predicting the need for clarification. This method is based on the measured coherency of results from an initial answer retrieval step, under the assumption that a less ambiguous query is more likely to retrieve more coherent results when compared to an ambiguous query. We build a graph from retrieved items based on their context similarity, treating measures of graph connectivity as indicators of ambiguity. We evaluate our approach on two recently released open-domain conversational question answering datasets, ClariQ and AmbigNQ, comparing it with neural and non-neural baselines. Our unsupervised approach performs as well as supervised approaches while providing better generalization.