Superiorization as a novel strategy for linearly constrained inverse radiotherapy treatment planning

TL;DR

This paper introduces superiorization as a new approach for IMRT treatment planning, perturbing feasibility-seeking algorithms with gradient steps to efficiently reduce nonlinear objectives, offering a promising alternative to traditional constrained optimization methods.

Contribution

It demonstrates the application of superiorization to radiotherapy planning, integrating it into an open-source toolkit and comparing its performance with existing methods.

Findings

Superiorization achieves similar plan quality to nonlinear optimization.

It exhibits smooth convergence in both constraints and objectives.

It offers a viable alternative to traditional optimization in radiotherapy planning.

Abstract

We apply the superiorization methodology to the intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT) treatment planning problem. In superiorization, linear voxel dose inequality constraints are the fundamental modeling tool within which a feasibility-seeking projection algorithm will seek a feasible point. This algorithm is then perturbed with gradient descent steps to reduce a nonlinear objective function. Within the open-source inverse planning toolkit matRad, we implement a prototypical algorithmic framework for superiorization using the well-established Agmon, Motzkin, and Schoenberg (AMS) feasibility-seeking projection algorithm and common nonlinear dose optimization objective functions. Based on this prototype, we apply superiorization to intensity-modulated radiation therapy treatment planning and compare its performance with feasibility-seeking and nonlinear constrained optimization. For these comparisons, we use the TG119 water phantom and a head-and-neck patient of the CORT dataset. Bare feasibility-seeking with AMS confirms previous studies, showing it can find solutions that are nearly equivalent to those found by the established piece-wise least-squares optimization approach. The superiorization prototype solved the linearly constrained planning problem with similar performance to that of a general-purpose nonlinear constrained optimizer while showing smooth convergence in both constraint proximity and objective function reduction. Superiorization is a useful alternative to constrained optimization in radiotherapy inverse treatment planning. Future extensions with other approaches to feasibility-seeking, e.g., with dose-volume constraints and more sophisticated perturbations, may unlock its full potential for high-performant inverse treatment planning.