ir_metadata: An Extensible Metadata Schema for IR Experiments

TL;DR

This paper introduces ir_metadata, an extensible schema for annotating IR experiment run files with metadata based on the PRIMAD model, enhancing reproducibility and reuse of experimental data.

Contribution

It proposes a new metadata schema aligned with PRIMAD for IR experiments and demonstrates its application in reproducibility studies and dataset curation.

Findings

Metadata annotations improve experiment reproducibility.

Implementation supports reproducibility studies in IR.

Annotated dataset facilitates reuse and validation.

Abstract

The information retrieval (IR) community has a strong tradition of making the computational artifacts and resources available for future reuse, allowing the validation of experimental results. Besides the actual test collections, the underlying run files are often hosted in data archives as part of conferences like TREC, CLEF, or NTCIR. Unfortunately, the run data itself does not provide much information about the underlying experiment. For instance, the single run file is not of much use without the context of the shared task's website or the run data archive. In other domains, like the social sciences, it is good practice to annotate research data with metadata. In this work, we introduce ir_metadata - an extensible metadata schema for TREC run files based on the PRIMAD model. We propose to align the metadata annotations to PRIMAD, which considers components of computational experiments that can affect reproducibility. Furthermore, we outline important components and information that should be reported in the metadata and give evidence from the literature. To demonstrate the usefulness of these metadata annotations, we implement new features in repro_eval that support the outlined metadata schema for the use case of reproducibility studies. Additionally, we curate a dataset with run files derived from experiments with different instantiations of PRIMAD components and annotate these with the corresponding metadata. In the experiments, we cover reproducibility experiments that are identified by the metadata and classified by PRIMAD. With this work, we enable IR researchers to annotate TREC run files and improve the reuse value of experimental artifacts even further.