NaCo2(SeO3)2(OH): Competing Magnetic Ground States of a New Sawtooth Structure with 3d7 Co2+ Ions

TL;DR

This paper reports the synthesis and detailed magnetic characterization of NaCo2(SeO3)2(OH), a new material with a frustrated sawtooth chain structure exhibiting competing magnetic ground states and complex magnetic ordering phenomena.

Contribution

It introduces a new sawtooth-structured material with 3d7 Co2+ ions, revealing competing magnetic ground states and complex magnetic ordering through synthesis and neutron diffraction analysis.

Findings

Ferromagnetic transition at 11 K with Co(2) site ordering.

Antiferromagnetic transition at 6 K with combined Co(1) and Co(2) ordering.

Complex magnetic structure with orthogonal and canted moments.

Abstract

While certain magnetic sublattices have long been known theoretically to give rise to emergent physics via competing magnetic interactions and quantum effects, finding such configurations in real materials is often deeply challenging. Here we report the synthesis and characterization of a new such material, NaCo2(SeO3)2(OH) which crystallizes with a highly frustrated sublattice of sawtooth Co2+ chains. Single crystals of NaCo2(SeO3)2(OH) were synthesized using a low-temperature hydrothermal method. X-ray single crystal structure analysis reveals that the material crystallizes in orthorhombic space group of Pnma (no. 62). Its crystal structure exhibits one-dimensional chains of corner-sharing isosceles triangles that are made of two crystallographically distinct 3d7 Co2+ sites (Co(1) and Co(2)). The chains run along the b-axis and are interconnected via [SeO3] groups to form a three-dimensional structure mediating super-exchange interactions. The temperature dependent magnetization data show a ferromagnetic-like (FM) transition at 11 K (T1) followed by an antiferromagnetic (AFM) transition at about 6 K (T2). Neutron-powder diffraction measurements reveal that at T1 = 11 K only Co(2) site orders magnetically, forming ferromagnetic zigzag chains along the b-axis. Below T2 = 6 K, both Co(1) and Co(2) sites order in an nearly orthogonal configuration, with Co(1) moments lying inside the plane of the sawtooth chain while Co(2) moments cant out of the plane. The canting of the magnetic moments leads to a net ferromagnetic component along b-axis, parallel to the chain direction. The ordered moments are fully compensated in the ac-plane.