pyKT: A Python Library to Benchmark Deep Learning based Knowledge Tracing Models

TL;DR

pyKT is a comprehensive Python benchmark platform for deep learning-based knowledge tracing, standardizing data preprocessing and evaluation to enable fair comparisons and insights into model performance.

Contribution

The paper introduces pyKT, a standardized, open-source benchmark library for deep learning knowledge tracing models, addressing experimental inconsistencies and enabling rigorous evaluation.

Findings

Many DLKT approaches show minimal improvement over early models

Incorrect evaluation protocols can lead to inflated performance metrics

Standardized procedures reveal limited gains from recent DLKT methods

Abstract

Knowledge tracing (KT) is the task of using students' historical learning interaction data to model their knowledge mastery over time so as to make predictions on their future interaction performance. Recently, remarkable progress has been made of using various deep learning techniques to solve the KT problem. However, the success behind deep learning based knowledge tracing (DLKT) approaches is still left somewhat unknown and proper measurement and analysis of these DLKT approaches remain a challenge. First, data preprocessing procedures in existing works are often private and custom, which limits experimental standardization. Furthermore, existing DLKT studies often differ in terms of the evaluation protocol and are far away real-world educational contexts. To address these problems, we introduce a comprehensive python based benchmark platform, \textsc{pyKT}, to guarantee valid comparisons across DLKT methods via thorough evaluations. The \textsc{pyKT} library consists of a standardized set of integrated data preprocessing procedures on 7 popular datasets across different domains, and 10 frequently compared DLKT model implementations for transparent experiments. Results from our fine-grained and rigorous empirical KT studies yield a set of observations and suggestions for effective DLKT, e.g., wrong evaluation setting may cause label leakage that generally leads to performance inflation; and the improvement of many DLKT approaches is minimal compared to the very first DLKT model proposed by Piech et al. \cite{piech2015deep}. We have open sourced \textsc{pyKT} and our experimental results at https://pykt.org/. We welcome contributions from other research groups and practitioners.