Investigating S-type asteroid surfaces through reflectance spectra of Ordinary Chondrites

TL;DR

This study analyzes the reflectance spectra of ordinary chondrites and S-type asteroids to understand surface compositions and classifications, revealing challenges in distinguishing equilibrated from unequilibrated types and correlations with asteroid size.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive spectral comparison between chondrites and S-type asteroids, highlighting classification challenges and surface grain size correlations.

Findings

No clear spectral dichotomy between UOCs and EOCs.

Larger S-type asteroids tend to have finer-grained surfaces.

Misclassification rate of Antarctic UOCs is 74%.

Abstract

We present an in-depth study of the reflectance spectra of 39 equilibrated and 41 unequilibrated ordinary chondrites. We demonstrate that consistent measuring conditions are vital for the direct comparison of spectral features between chondrites, otherwise hampering any conclusions. We include a comparison with a total of 466 S-type asteroid reflectance spectra. We analyze (i) if a difference between EOCs and UOCs as well as between H, L and LL can be seen, (ii) if it is possible to identify unequilibrated and equilibrated S-type asteroid surfaces and (iii) if we can further constrain the match between OCs and S-type asteroids all based on reflectance spectra. We checked the classification of the 31 Antarctic UOCs analyzed in the present work, using petrography and magnetic measurements, and evidenced that 74% of them were misclassified. Reflectance spectra were compared between EOCs and UOCs as well as between H, L and LL chondrites using a set of spectral features including band depths and positions, peak reflectance values, spectral slopes and the Ol/(Ol + Px) ratio. UOCs and EOCs reflectance spectra show no clear-cut dichotomy, but a continuum with some EOCs showing stronger absorption bands and peak reflectance values, while others are comparable to UOCs. We show by the example of 6 EOCs that their band depths decrease with decreasing grain size. Based on reflectance spectra alone, it is thus highly challenging to objectively identify an unequilibrated from an equilibrated S-type surface. There is no clear distinction of the chemical groups: only LL EOCs of petrographic type > 4 can be distinguished from H and L through less deep 2-mic band depths and 1-mic band positions at longer wavelengths. Lastly, an anti-correlation between the diameter of the asteroids and their 1000 nm band depth is found indicating that larger sized S-type asteroids show finer grained surfaces.