Hamilton's Principle with Phase Changes and Conservation Principles for Moist Potential Vorticity

TL;DR

This paper develops a Hamiltonian framework to derive conservation laws for moist potential vorticity, incorporating phase changes and cloud dynamics, and establishes conditions under which moist PV is a material invariant.

Contribution

It introduces a systematic variational approach using Noether's theorem to derive conservation laws for moist PV with phase changes, addressing limitations of previous definitions.

Findings

Moist PV conservation law derived from particle relabeling symmetry.

A moist Kelvin circulation theorem established for a Boussinesq system.

Energy and Lagrangian density are smooth enough for variational derivatives despite phase changes.

Abstract

Many definitions of moist potential vorticity (PV) have been proposed to extend the dry theory of Ertel PV. None of the moist PV definitions seem to have all of the desirable properties of the dry Ertel PV. For instance, dry PV is not only a globally conserved quantity, but also a material invariant that is conserved along fluid parcel trajectories. Therefore, an open question remains: is there a moist PV that is a material invariant, if clouds and phase changes of water are present? In prior studies, definitions of moist PV have been proposed based on physical and mathematical intuition. Here, a systematic approach is used. In particular, a particle relabeling symmetry is devised for a moist atmosphere and then Noether's theorem is employed to arrive at the associated conservation laws for moist PV. A priori, it is not clear whether this systematic approach will be viable, since it relies on variational derivatives in Hamilton's principle, and phase changes introduce singularities that could potentially prevent derivatives at cloud edge. However, it is shown that the energy and the Lagrangian density are sufficiently smooth to allow variational derivatives, in a moist Boussinesq system with reversible phase transitions between water vapor and liquid cloud water.. From the particle relabeling symmetry, a moist Kelvin circulation theorem is found, along with a moist PV conservation law that applies not for each individual parcel but for parcel-integrated PV, integrated over certain local volumes.