Resolution Limits of Resonant Sensors with Duffing Non-Linearity

TL;DR

This paper investigates how Duffing non-linearity affects the fundamental resolution limits of resonant sensors, revealing conditions where increasing quality factor can enhance resolution, supported by analytical modeling, simulations, and experimental validation.

Contribution

It provides a new analytical model for Duffing resonators' resolution limits and demonstrates that optimizing quality factor can improve sensing resolution under certain conditions.

Findings

Higher quality factors can improve resolution in non-linear resonators.

The analytical model matches numerical simulations and experimental results.

Resolutions surpassing previous limits are experimentally achieved.

Abstract

The resolution of resonant sensors is fundamentally limited by the presence of noise. Thermomechanical noise, intrinsic to the resonator, sets the ultimate sensor performance when all other noise sources have been eliminated. For linear resonators, the sensing resolution can always be further improved by increasing the driving power. However, this trend cannot continue indefinitely, since at sufficiently high driving powers non-linear effects emerge and influence the noise performance. As a consequence, the resonator's non-linear characteristics play an inextricable role in determining its ultimate resolution limits. Recently, several works have studied the characteristic performance of non-linear resonators as sensors, with the counter intuitive conclusion that increasing the quality factor of a resonator does not improve its sensing resolution at the thermomechanical limit. In this work we further analyze the ultimate resolution limits, and describe different regimes of performance at integration times below and above the resonator's decay time. We provide an analytical model to elucidate the effects of Duffing non-linearity on the resolution of closed-loop sensors, and validate it using numerical simulations. In contrast to previous works, our model and simulations show that under certain conditions the ultimate sensing resolution of a Duffing resonator can be improved by maximizing its quality factor. With measurements on a nanomechanical membrane resonator, we experimentally verify the model and demonstrate that frequency resolutions can be achieved that surpass the previously known limits.