Restricted Nim with a Pass

TL;DR

This paper investigates the impact of a single pass move on restricted Nim, revealing that the pass minimally affects the game's structure and maintaining its full solvability.

Contribution

It demonstrates a simple relationship between Grundy numbers of restricted Nim with and without a pass, solving a longstanding open problem in combinatorial game theory.

Findings

Pass move has minimal impact on game complexity

Restricted Nim remains fully solvable with a pass

Established a relationship between Grundy numbers with and without pass

Abstract

This paper presents a study of restricted Nim with a pass. In the restricted Nim considered in this study, two players take turns and remove stones from the piles. In each turn, when the number of stones is m, each player is allowed to remove at least one stone and at most the ceiling of m/2 stones from a pile of m stones. The standard rules of the game are modified to allow a one-time pass, that is, a pass move that may be used at most once in the game and not from a terminal position. Once a pass has been used by either player, it is no longer available. It is well-known that in classical Nim, the introduction of the pass alters the underlying structure of the game, significantly increasing its complexity. In the restricted Nim considered in this study, the pass move was found to have a minimal impact. There is a simple relationship between the Grundy numbers of restricted Nim and the Grundy numbers of restricted Nim with a pass, where the number of piles can be any natural number. Therefore, the authors address a longstanding open question in combinatorial game theory: the extent to which the introduction of a pass into a game affects its behavior. The game that we developed appears to be the first variant of Nim that is fully solvable when a pass is not allowed and remains fully solvable following the introduction of a pass move.