Comment on "Thermodynamic Principle for Quantum Metrology"

TL;DR

This paper critically examines a recent claim linking thermodynamic cost and quantum Fisher information in quantum metrology, showing that the proposed inequality is trivial or violated in some cases, thus questioning its validity.

Contribution

The authors identify flaws in the proposed inequality relating measurement entropy and quantum Fisher information, demonstrating it reduces to a trivial statement or can be violated.

Findings

The inequality reduces to a trivial inequality in the considered setting.

Optimal measurements can violate the proposed inequality for some states.

The entropy of optimal measurements is bounded between 0 and log(2).

Abstract

In Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 200501 (2022) the authors consider the thermodynamic cost of quantum metrology. One of the main results is $\mathcal{S} \geq \log(2) \| h_\lambda \|^{-2} F_Q [\psi_\lambda]$, which purports to relate the Shannon entropy $\mathcal{S}$ of an optimal measurement (i.e., in the basis of the symmetric logarithmic derivative) to the quantum Fisher information $F_Q$ of the pure state $|\psi_\lambda\rangle$. However, we show that in the setting considered by the authors we have $\mathcal{S} = \log(2)$ and $\| h_\lambda \|^{2} = \max_{\psi_\lambda} F_Q[\psi_\lambda]$, so that their inequality reduces to the trivial inequality $\max_{\psi_\lambda} F_Q[\psi_\lambda] \geq F_Q[\psi_\lambda]$, and does not in fact relate the entropy $\mathcal{S}$ to the quantum Fisher information. Moreover, for pure state quantum metrology, there exist optimal measurements (though not in the basis of the symmetric logarithmic derivative) for which $0 \leq \mathcal{S} \leq \log(2)$, leading to violations of the inequality for some states $|\psi_\lambda\rangle$.