The gravitational field of X-COP galaxy clusters

TL;DR

This study uses deep X-ray and Sunyaev-Zeldovich data from 12 galaxy clusters to precisely measure their gravitational fields, confirming the NFW profile's accuracy and exploring baryonic contributions, with implications for dark matter and gravity theories.

Contribution

It provides the first detailed gravitational field measurements of galaxy clusters over a wide radial range, testing the NFW profile and baryonic effects with unprecedented precision.

Findings

NFW profile fits mass profiles within 10% accuracy

Average concentration matches $ m extLambda$CDM predictions

Baryonic matter contributes minimally beyond 0.02 R_{500}

Abstract

The mass profiles of massive dark matter halos are highly sensitive to the nature of dark matter and potential modifications of the theory of gravity on large scales. The $\Lambda$CDM paradigm makes strong predictions on the shape of dark matter halos and on the dependence of the shape parameters on halo mass, such that any deviation from the predicted universal shape would have important implications for the fundamental properties of dark matter. Here we use a set of 12 galaxy clusters with available deep X-ray and Sunyaev-Zeldovich data to constrain the shape of the gravitational field with an unprecedented level of precision over two decades in radius. On average, we find that the NFW profile provides an excellent description of the recovered mass profiles, with deviations of less than 10% over a wide radial range. However, there appears to be more diversity in the shape of individual profiles than can be captured by the NFW model. The average NFW concentration and its scatter agree very well with the prediction of the $\Lambda$CDM framework. For a subset of systems, we disentangle the gravitational field into the contribution of baryonic components (gas, brightest cluster galaxy, and satellite galaxies) and that of dark matter. The stellar content dominates the gravitational field inside $\sim0.02R_{500}$ but is responsible for only 1-2% of the total gravitational field inside $R_{200}$. The total baryon fraction reaches the cosmic value at $R_{200}$ and slightly exceeds it beyond this point, possibly indicating a mild level of nonthermal pressure support ($10-20\%$) in cluster outskirts. Finally, the relation between observed and baryonic acceleration exhibits a complex shape that strongly departs from the radial acceleration relation in spiral galaxies, which shows that the aforementioned relation does not hold at the galaxy-cluster scale.