Local adaptation, phenotypic plasticity, and species coexistence

TL;DR

This study investigates how phenotypic plasticity enables species coexistence in spatially variable environments, even without ecological differentiation, through individual-based stochastic simulations.

Contribution

It demonstrates that phenotypic plasticity can facilitate coexistence of competing species in heterogeneous landscapes without niche differentiation.

Findings

Plastic species coexist with non-plastic competitors under high migration and environmental variance.

Local adaptation and gene flow promote genetic variation and coexistence.

Phenotypic plasticity allows inferior competitors to persist alongside superior ones.

Abstract

Understanding the mechanisms of species coexistence has always been a fundamental topic in ecology. Classical theory predicts that interspecific competition may select for traits that stabilize niche differences, although recent work shows that this is not strictly necessary. Here we ask whether adaptive phenotypic plasticity could allow species coexistence (i.e., some stability at an equilibrium point) without ecological differentiation in habitat use. We used individual-based stochastic simulations defining a landscape composed of spatially uncorrelated or autocorrelated environmental patches, where two species with the same competitive strategies, not able to coexist without some form of phenotypic plasticity, expanded their ranges in the absence of a competition-colonization trade-off (a well-studied mechanism for species diversity). Each patch is characterized by a random environmental value that determines the optimal phenotype of its occupants. In such a scenario, only local adaptation and gene flow (migration) may interact to promote genetic variation and coexistence in the metapopulation. Results show that a competitively inferior species with adaptive phenotypic plasticity can coexist in a same patch with a competitively superior, non-plastic species, provided the migration rates and variances of the patches' environmental values are sufficiently large.