Segmenting across places: The need for fair transfer learning with satellite imagery

TL;DR

This paper examines the fairness of transfer learning in satellite image segmentation across different locations, revealing disparities in model performance between urban and rural areas and emphasizing the need for fair transfer methods.

Contribution

It provides a systematic fairness analysis of transfer learning in satellite imagery segmentation and highlights the disparities between urban and rural areas.

Findings

Models perform better in rural areas overall.

Unsupervised domain adaptation favors urban areas, widening fairness gaps.

Rural images are more dissimilar between source and target districts.

Abstract

The increasing availability of high-resolution satellite imagery has enabled the use of machine learning to support land-cover measurement and inform policy-making. However, labelling satellite images is expensive and is available for only some locations. This prompts the use of transfer learning to adapt models from data-rich locations to others. Given the potential for high-impact applications of satellite imagery across geographies, a systematic assessment of transfer learning implications is warranted. In this work, we consider the task of land-cover segmentation and study the fairness implications of transferring models across locations. We leverage a large satellite image segmentation benchmark with 5987 images from 18 districts (9 urban and 9 rural). Via fairness metrics we quantify disparities in model performance along two axes -- across urban-rural locations and across land-cover classes. Findings show that state-of-the-art models have better overall accuracy in rural areas compared to urban areas, through unsupervised domain adaptation methods transfer learning better to urban versus rural areas and enlarge fairness gaps. In analysis of reasons for these findings, we show that raw satellite images are overall more dissimilar between source and target districts for rural than for urban locations. This work highlights the need to conduct fairness analysis for satellite imagery segmentation models and motivates the development of methods for fair transfer learning in order not to introduce disparities between places, particularly urban and rural locations.