Price Optimal Routing in Public Transportation

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new framework called conditional fare networks for modeling complex fare structures in public transit, enabling efficient optimal routing considering both price and arrival time.

Contribution

The paper presents CFNs as a novel modeling approach for complex fare systems and adapts the MCRAP algorithm to solve the price optimal routing problem efficiently.

Findings

CFNs can model diverse real-world fare structures.

The adapted MCRAP algorithm finds optimal routes in under 400 ms.

Restricting Pareto-set size reduces computation time below 10 ms.

Abstract

We consider the price-optimal earliest arrival problem in public transit (POEAP) in which we aim to calculate the Pareto-set of journeys with respect to ticket price and arrival time in a public transportation network. Public transit fare structures are often a combination of various fare strategies such as, e.g., distance-based fares, zone-based fares or flat fares. The rules that determine the actual ticket price are often very complex. Accordingly, fare structures are notoriously difficult to model, as it is in general not sufficient to simply assign costs to arcs in a routing graph. Research into POEAP is scarce and usually either relies on heuristics or only considers restrictive fare models that are too limited to cover the full scope of most real-world applications. We therefore introduce conditional fare networks (CFNs), the first framework for representing a large number of real-world fare structures. We show that by relaxing label domination criteria, CFNs can be used as a building block in label-setting multi-objective shortest path algorithms. By the nature of their extensive modeling capabilities, optimizing over CFNs is NP-hard. However, we demonstrate that adapting the multi-criteria RAPTOR (MCRAP) algorithm for CFNs yields an algorithm capable of solving POEAP to optimality in less than 400 ms on average on a real-world data set. By restricting the size of the Pareto-set, running times are further reduced to below 10 ms.