To Find Waldo You Need Contextual Cues: Debiasing Who's Waldo

TL;DR

This paper introduces a debiased dataset for the Person-centric Visual Grounding task, reducing biases present in the original dataset to enable more accurate benchmarking of models.

Contribution

The authors develop automated tools to filter and debias the dataset, creating a more balanced benchmark for PCVG that mitigates heuristic shortcuts.

Findings

Debiased dataset reduces model bias and heuristic performance.

Models trained on the debiased dataset outperform those trained on the original.

Wider gap between heuristic and supervised methods indicates improved evaluation.

Abstract

We present a debiased dataset for the Person-centric Visual Grounding (PCVG) task first proposed by Cui et al. (2021) in the Who's Waldo dataset. Given an image and a caption, PCVG requires pairing up a person's name mentioned in a caption with a bounding box that points to the person in the image. We find that the original Who's Waldo dataset compiled for this task contains a large number of biased samples that are solvable simply by heuristic methods; for instance, in many cases the first name in the sentence corresponds to the largest bounding box, or the sequence of names in the sentence corresponds to an exact left-to-right order in the image. Naturally, models trained on these biased data lead to over-estimation of performance on the benchmark. To enforce models being correct for the correct reasons, we design automated tools to filter and debias the original dataset by ruling out all examples of insufficient context, such as those with no verb or with a long chain of conjunct names in their captions. Our experiments show that our new sub-sampled dataset contains less bias with much lowered heuristic performances and widened gaps between heuristic and supervised methods. We also demonstrate the same benchmark model trained on our debiased training set outperforms that trained on the original biased (and larger) training set on our debiased test set. We argue our debiased dataset offers the PCVG task a more practical baseline for reliable benchmarking and future improvements.