Ambipolar diffusion: Self-similar solutions and MHD code testing. Cylindrical symmetry

TL;DR

This paper derives self-similar solutions for ambipolar diffusion in cylindrical symmetry to serve as rigorous tests for MHD codes, and evaluates the Bifrost code's accuracy in reproducing these solutions.

Contribution

It presents new theoretical self-similar solutions for ambipolar diffusion in cylindrical symmetry and demonstrates their use as stringent tests for MHD simulation codes.

Findings

Theoretical solutions are eigenfunctions of a nonlinear ODE.

Bifrost code accurately reproduces the solutions.

Solutions serve as demanding tests for MHD codes with ambipolar diffusion.

Abstract

Ambipolar diffusion is a process occurring in partially ionised astrophysical systems that imparts a complicated mathematical and physical nature to Ohm's law. The numerical codes that solve the magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) equations have to be able to deal with the singularities that are naturally created in the system by the ambipolar diffusion term. The global aim is to calculate a set of theoretical self-similar solutions to the nonlinear diffusion equation with cylindrical symmetry that can be used as tests for MHD codes which include the ambipolar diffusion term. First, following the general methods developed in the applied mathematics literature, we obtained the theoretical solutions as eigenfunctions of a nonlinear ordinary differential equation. Phase-plane techniques were used to integrate through the singularities at the locations of the nulls, which correspond to infinitely sharp current sheets. In the second half of the paper, we consider the use of these solutions as tests for MHD codes. To that end, we used the Bifrost code, thereby testing the capabilities of these solutions as tests as well as (inversely) the accuracy of Bifrost's recently developed ambipolar diffusion module. The obtained solutions are shown to constitute a demanding, but nonetheless viable, test for MHD codes that incorporate ambipolar diffusion. The Bifrost code is able to reproduce the theoretical solutions with sufficient accuracy up to very advanced diffusive times. Using the code, we also explored the asymptotic properties of our theoretical solutions in time when initially perturbed with either small or finite perturbations. The functions obtained in this paper are relevant as physical solutions and also as tests for general MHD codes. They provide a more stringent and general test than the simple Zeldovich-Kompaneets-Barenblatt-Pattle solution.