A Transdisciplinary Approach for Generating Synthetic but Realistic Domestic Sex Trafficking Networks

TL;DR

This paper introduces a network generator for domestic sex trafficking that combines operational research and qualitative data to produce realistic, anonymized networks for policy analysis and disruption strategies.

Contribution

It presents a novel approach integrating OR concepts with qualitative research to generate realistic trafficking networks without compromising privacy.

Findings

Generated networks reflect real trafficking relationships.

Trafficker flow control impacts victim recruitment.

Disruption strategies influence trafficker behavior.

Abstract

One of the major challenges associated with applying operations research (OR) models to disrupting human trafficking networks is the limited amount of reliable data sources readily available for public use, since operations are intentionally hidden to prevent detection, and data from known operations are often incomplete. To help address this data gap, we propose a network generator for domestic sex trafficking networks by integrating OR concepts and qualitative research. Multiple sources regarding sex trafficking in the upper Midwest of the United States have been triangulated to ensure that networks produced by the generator are realistic, including law enforcement case file analysis, interviews with domain experts, and a survivor-centered advisory group with first-hand knowledge of sex trafficking. The output models the relationships between traffickers, so-called "bottoms", and victims. This generator allows operations researchers to access realistic sex trafficking network structures in a responsible manner that does not disclose identifiable details of the people involved. We demonstrate the use of output networks in exploring policy recommendations from max flow network interdiction with restructuring. To do so, we propose a novel conceptualization of flow as the ability of a trafficker to control their victims. Our results show the importance of understanding how sex traffickers react to disruptions, especially in terms of recruiting new victims.