A study on the distribution of social biases in self-supervised learning visual models

TL;DR

This paper investigates social biases in self-supervised visual models trained on ImageNet, revealing that bias presence varies with model type and can be mitigated through careful selection without sacrificing performance.

Contribution

It provides an empirical analysis of social biases in SSL visual models, demonstrating the correlation with model type and offering insights for bias reduction strategies.

Findings

Bias varies with SSL model type

Bias number does not strictly depend on accuracy

Careful model selection can reduce biases

Abstract

Deep neural networks are efficient at learning the data distribution if it is sufficiently sampled. However, they can be strongly biased by non-relevant factors implicitly incorporated in the training data. These include operational biases, such as ineffective or uneven data sampling, but also ethical concerns, as the social biases are implicitly present\textemdash even inadvertently, in the training data or explicitly defined in unfair training schedules. In tasks having impact on human processes, the learning of social biases may produce discriminatory, unethical and untrustworthy consequences. It is often assumed that social biases stem from supervised learning on labelled data, and thus, Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) wrongly appears as an efficient and bias-free solution, as it does not require labelled data. However, it was recently proven that a popular SSL method also incorporates biases. In this paper, we study the biases of a varied set of SSL visual models, trained using ImageNet data, using a method and dataset designed by psychological experts to measure social biases. We show that there is a correlation between the type of the SSL model and the number of biases that it incorporates. Furthermore, the results also suggest that this number does not strictly depend on the model's accuracy and changes throughout the network. Finally, we conclude that a careful SSL model selection process can reduce the number of social biases in the deployed model, whilst keeping high performance.