A review on geometric constraint solving

TL;DR

This review comprehensively covers the last 15 years of geometric constraint solving in CAD, highlighting advances in handling general constraint systems, their challenges, and future directions.

Contribution

It provides a detailed overview of recent developments in geometric constraint solving, especially for general systems with complex dependencies, filling a gap left by earlier reviews.

Findings

Progress in classification criteria and decomposition algorithms for general constraint systems

Detection and resolution of under- and over-constrained parts in constraint systems

Identification of remaining challenges and future research directions

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive review of geometric constraint solving in parametric computer-aided design (CAD), with the major focus on its advances in the last 15 years. Geometric constraint solving can date back to the very first CAD prototype, Sketchpad, in the 1960s, but serious research studies were carried out only after parametric CAD was introduced in the late 1980s. In the following 30-year history of GCS research, two development stages may be identified: (1) the first 15 years (late 1980s - mid 2000s) were primarily devoted to geometric constraint decomposition for well-constrained systems or those with only structural constraint dependencies; and (2) the second 15 years (late 2000s - now) have seen research efforts shifted towards classification criteria and decomposition algorithms for general constraint systems (with and without non-structural constraint dependencies). Most existing reviews focused on the first 15 years. The problem researched in the second 15 years is, however, equally important, considering that a manually specified constraint system usually contains under- and over-constrained parts, and that such parts must be correctly detected and resolved before numerical solving can work. In this regard, this review paper covers both stages and will discusses what has already been made possible for handling general constraint systems, what developments can be expected in the near future, and which areas remain problematic.