Evaluation of indirect damage and damage saturation effects in dose-response curves of hypofractionated radiotherapy of early-stage NSCLC and brain metastases

TL;DR

This study compares different models to understand how indirect damage and damage saturation affect tumor control in hypofractionated radiotherapy for early-stage NSCLC and brain metastases, providing insights for optimizing treatment strategies.

Contribution

It introduces a comparative analysis of dose-response models incorporating indirect damage and saturation effects, highlighting model preferences for NSCLC and brain metastases.

Findings

Modified LQ-model fits NSCLC data better, indicating indirect damage effects.

LQL model best fits brain metastases data, suggesting damage saturation.

Results depend on alpha/beta ratios, especially for NSCLC.

Abstract

Background and purpose: To investigate the possible contribution of indirect damage and damage saturation to tumour control obtained with SBRT/SRS treatments for early-stage NSCLC and brain metastases. Methods and Materials: We have constructed a dataset of early-stage NSCLC and brain metastases dose-response. These data were fitted to models based on the linear-quadratic (LQ), the linear-quadratic-linear (LQL), and phenomenological modifications of the LQ-model to account for indirect cell damage. We use the Akaike-Information-Criterion formalism to compare performance, and studied the stability of the results with changes in fitting parameters and perturbations on dose/TCP values. Results: In NSCLC, a modified LQ-model with a beta-term increasing with dose yields the best-fits for $\alpha$/$\beta$=10 Gy. Only the inclusion of very fast accelerated proliferation or low $\alpha$/$\beta$ values can eliminate such superiority. In brain, the LQL model yields the best-fits, and the ranking is not affected by variations of fitting parameters or dose/TCP perturbations. Conclusions: For $\alpha$/$\beta$=10 Gy, a modified LQ-model with a beta-term increasing with dose provides better fits to NSCLC dose-response curves. For brain metastases, the LQL provides the best fit. This might be interpreted as a hint of indirect damage in NSCLC, and damage saturation in brain metastases. The results for NSCLC are strongly dependent on the value of $\alpha$/$\beta$ and may require further investigation, while those for brain seem to be clearly significant. Our results can assist in the design of improved radiotherapy for NSCLC and brain metastases, aiming at avoiding over/under-treatment.