Learning Mechanically Driven Emergent Behavior with Message Passing Neural Networks

TL;DR

This paper explores the use of Graph Neural Networks to predict buckling behavior in asymmetric columns, introducing a new dataset and analyzing factors affecting model performance in solid mechanics.

Contribution

The study introduces the ABC dataset for buckling prediction, evaluates GNN architectures and data representations, and highlights challenges in modeling emergent mechanical behaviors.

Findings

GNNs can predict buckling direction with good accuracy

Data representation and augmentation significantly impact performance

Modeling emergent behavior remains a complex challenge

Abstract

From designing architected materials to connecting mechanical behavior across scales, computational modeling is a critical tool in solid mechanics. Recently, there has been a growing interest in using machine learning to reduce the computational cost of physics-based simulations. Notably, while machine learning approaches that rely on Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have shown success in learning mechanics, the performance of GNNs has yet to be investigated on a myriad of solid mechanics problems. In this work, we examine the ability of GNNs to predict a fundamental aspect of mechanically driven emergent behavior: the connection between a column's geometric structure and the direction that it buckles. To accomplish this, we introduce the Asymmetric Buckling Columns (ABC) dataset, a dataset comprised of three sub-datasets of asymmetric and heterogeneous column geometries where the goal is to classify the direction of symmetry breaking (left or right) under compression after the onset of instability. Because of complex local geometry, the "image-like" data representations required for implementing standard convolutional neural network based metamodels are not ideal, thus motivating the use of GNNs. In addition to investigating GNN model architecture, we study the effect of different input data representation approaches, data augmentation, and combining multiple models as an ensemble. While we were able to obtain good results, we also showed that predicting solid mechanics based emergent behavior is non-trivial. Because both our model implementation and dataset are distributed under open-source licenses, we hope that future researchers can build on our work to create enhanced mechanics-specific machine learning pipelines for capturing the behavior of complex geometric structures.