Operating Spacecraft Around Comets: Evaluation of the Near-Nucleus Environment

TL;DR

This study evaluates the hazards and operational considerations for spacecraft near comet nuclei, concluding that with proper design and planning, such environments are relatively safe for long-term missions despite active comet activity.

Contribution

The paper provides a comprehensive assessment of the near-nucleus environment, combining simple calculations, engineering models, and recent mission experiences to inform future spacecraft operations around comets.

Findings

Near-nucleus environment is safer than expected with proper planning.

Dust densities are comparable to cleanroom conditions, allowing manageable operations.

Modern attitude control systems can handle stochastic forces with minimal navigation errors.

Abstract

We present a study of the current state of knowledge concerning spacecraft operations and potential hazards while operating near a comet nucleus. Starting from simple calculations comparing the cometary coma environment to benign conditions on Earth, we progress to sophisticated engineering models of spacecraft behavior, and then confront these models with recent spacecraft proximity operations experience. Finally, we make recommendations from lessons learned for future spacecraft missions that enter into orbit around a comet for long-term operations. All of these considerations indicate that, with a proper spacecraft design and operations planning, the near-nucleus environment can be a relatively safe region in which to operate, even for an active short period comet near perihelion with gas production rates as high as 1e29 molecules/s. With gas densities similar to those found in good laboratory vacuums, dust densities similar to Class 100 cleanrooms, dust particle velocities of 10s of m/s, and microgravity forces that permit slow and deliberate operations, the conditions around a comet are generally more benign than a typical day on Mars. Even in strong dust jets near the nucleus surface, dust densities tend to be only a few grains/cm3, about the same as in a typical interior room on Earth. Stochastic forces on a modern spacecraft with tens of square meters of projected surface area can be accounted for using modern Attitude Control Systems to within tens of meters navigation error; surface contamination issues are only important for spacecraft spending months to years within a few kilometers of the nucleus surface; and the issues the Rosetta spacecraft faced, confusion of celestial star trackers by sunlit dust particles flying past the spacecraft, will be addressed using the next generation of star trackers implementing improved transient rejection algorithms.