Relationship between Ca and H$\alpha$ chromospheric emission in F-G-K stars: indication of stellar filaments?

TL;DR

This study investigates the complex relationship between Hα and Ca II chromospheric emissions in F-G-K stars, suggesting that phenomena like filaments, beyond plages, are needed to explain observed emission patterns.

Contribution

The paper provides a detailed analysis of emission relationships in stars and demonstrates that plages alone cannot account for the observed emission variability, highlighting the potential role of filaments.

Findings

Anti-correlated emissions observed in some stars challenge existing models.

Plages alone cannot reproduce all observed emission relationships.

Filaments may be necessary to explain the diversity of emission patterns.

Abstract

Different relationships between the H$\alpha$ and Ca II chromospheric emissions have been reported in solar-type stars. In particular, the time-series of emissions in these two lines are clearly anti-correlated for a few percent of the stars, contrary to what is observed on the Sun. Our objective is to characterise these relationships in more detail using complementary criteria, and to constrain the properties of filaments and plages that are necessary to explain the observations. We analysed the average level and variability of the H$\alpha$ and Ca II emission for 441 F-G-K stars, paying particular attention to their (anti-)correlations on both short and long timescales. We also computed synthetic H$\alpha$ and Ca II time-series for different assumptions of plage and filament properties and compared them with the observations. We were not able to find plage properties that, alone, are sufficient to reproduce the observations at all timescales simultaneously, even when allowing different H$\alpha$ and Ca II emission relationships for different stars. We also specified the complex and surprising relationship between the average activity levels of both indexes, in particular for low-activity stars.We conclude that plages alone are unlikely to explain the observed variety of relationships between Ca II and H$\alpha$ emission, and that the presence of other phenomena like filaments may help to reconcile the models with observations.