Systematic Literature Review on Cyber Situational Awareness Visualizations

TL;DR

This systematic review analyzes 54 studies on cyber situational awareness visualizations, highlighting current practices, gaps, and future research directions to improve organizational cybersecurity understanding.

Contribution

It provides a comprehensive analysis of existing CSA visualization techniques, stakeholder focus, and identifies gaps in visualization coverage and maturity.

Findings

Most visualizations target operational staff

Lack of visualizations for managers and decision makers

Focus mainly on threat information, less on impact and response

Abstract

The dynamics of cyber threats are increasingly complex, making it more challenging than ever for organizations to obtain in-depth insights into their cyber security status. Therefore, organizations rely on Cyber Situational Awareness (CSA) to support them in better understanding the threats and associated impacts of cyber events. Due to the heterogeneity and complexity of cyber security data, often with multidimensional attributes, sophisticated visualization techniques are needed to achieve CSA. However, there have been no previous attempts to systematically review and analyze the scientific literature on CSA visualizations. In this paper, we systematically select and review 54 publications that discuss visualizations to support CSA. We extract data from these papers to identify key stakeholders, information types, data sources, and visualization techniques. Furthermore, we analyze the level of CSA supported by the visualizations, alongside examining the maturity of the visualizations, challenges, and practices related to CSA visualizations to prepare a full analysis of the current state of CSA in an organizational context. Our results reveal certain gaps in CSA visualizations. For instance, the largest focus is on operational-level staff, and there is a clear lack of visualizations targeting other types of stakeholders such as managers, higher-level decision makers, and non-expert users. Most papers focus on threat information visualization, and there is a dearth of papers that visualize impact information, response plans, and information shared within teams. Based on the results that highlight the important concerns in CSA visualizations, we recommend a list of future research directions.