Estimating the non-dimensional energy of vortex rings by modelling their roll-up

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new model based on vortex sheet roll-up to predict the non-dimensional energy of vortex rings, demonstrating its validity across different velocity profiles and aligning with experimental data.

Contribution

The authors develop an alternative vortex ring energy prediction model using self-similar vortex sheet roll-up, expanding understanding beyond traditional universal values.

Findings

Model predicts E* = 0.33 for constant velocity

Model predicts E* = 0.19 for constant acceleration

Vorticity diffusion aligns predictions with experimental results

Abstract

The non-dimensional energy of starting vortex rings typically converges to values around 0.33 when they are created by a cylinder piston or a bluff body translating at a constant speed. To explore the limits of the universality of this value and to analyse the variations that occur outside of those limits, we present an alternative approach to the slug-flow model to predict the non-dimensional energy of a vortex ring. Our approach is based on the self-similar vortex sheet roll-up described by Pullin. We derive the vorticity distribution for the vortex core resulting from a spiralling shear layer roll-up and compute the associated non-dimensional energy. To demonstrate the validity of our model, we consider different velocity profiles of the vortex generator that follow a power-law with a variable exponent m. For a constant velocity (m=0), our model yields a non-dimensional energy of E*=0.33. For a constant acceleration (m=1), we find E*=0.19. For a constant velocity, we obtain realistic vorticity distributions by radially diffusing the vorticity distribution of the Pullin spiral and predict a decrease of the non-dimensional energy from 0.33 to 0.28, in accordance with experimental results. Our proposed model offers a practical alternative to the existing slug flow model to predict the minimum non-dimensional energy of a vortex ring. The model is applicable to piston-generated and wake vortex rings and requires only the kinematics of the vortex generator as input.